Dear Hera and Robert,
First of all, let me thank both of you, from my heart, for this warm-heart conversation. I really feel alive again. Descartes said, "I think, therefore I am" but I might be in worse case, "I think, therefore I write, and so I am." (I've been earning my living as a writer for almost 30 years now. But I didn't always can write what I really wanted to if my editors stopped me with the reason, it never be sold. Well, a man had to eat, right? And idealism doesn't full your stomach; but food does, right?
Okay, back to this thread:
Hera said,
-You know what my first impression that made me keep studying I Ching for more than 30 years now? (I own more than 80 versions of its translations). I got some answer after asking some question. Then, my brain wanted to outsmart it, and immediately asked the same question again. Yes, you can guess what I got:
YOUTHFUL FOLLY has success.
It is not I who seek the young fool;
The young fool seeks me.
At the first oracle I inform him.
If he asks two or three times, it is importunity.
If he importunes, I give him no information.
(Well, I always knew that everyone is sensitive. But that time I just learned that even I Ching was, too).
After keep studying it for 35 years or so, I think I understand how it works (Hmm...or this will be my initial judgments again?). Let me brief it here.
Ancient men of wisdom had noticed that water went down (ward), air went up etc. This time of the year, we felt hot, that time cold. When the moon was full, the water flew, (after ebb) etc. And the same as in astrology, when this and that star appeared in that and that position of the sky, there were such and such events happened in the human world. So men of wisdom wrote them down all.
As for I Ching, it also works like an alcohol detector or even lies detector. I asked a question and got that exact answer (after I tossed coins or picked the yellow stalks) because I had that exact state of mind (conscious and unconscious) at that very exact moment. It's kind of body and mind (conscious and unconscious) connection. More than that, it helped me to do my honest self-critique. Wherether its warning would come true or not, I always could learn about myself more and more. Here's some of its wise words:
"You can also begin to understand the path you should follow by recognizing how the consequences of your actions return to affect you. Every
choice you make affects the world around you, and every action you take in the world has a reaction in your own life. What kind of feedback are you getting from your environment when you act in a certain way? If your habits work to make you feel healthier, happier, and more confident about yourself, you are probably headed in the right direction. But if your patterns of behavior repeatedly leave you feeling unhappy, lonely empty, and despairing, something is amiss."
.................................
-Great question!
I kind of agree (learned by bitter experiences in the past) with Hera when she said she believed they would have happened anyway. And as you asked, what the purpose of the warning was, then?
I believe it's about scope of learning? I mean, the warning made us to prepare something in advance. And if we failed to do that, at least, we can learn from our mistakes more easily than knowing nothing at all. If I got a warning in advance that it would rain, at least, I could bring my umbrella with me. It was better to have no umbrella when I really needed it. And if I went out without knowing that warning or didn’t believe in it, I would feel so terrible in the rain.
But that thing really happened because that warning (like in Neo's case above)? I mean we just made it happened because of ourselves, because of our self-fulfilling prophecy (the socio-psychological phenomenon of someone "predicting" or expecting something, and this “prediction” or expectation comes true simply because one believes it will)?
Hmm...I don't think so. The warning didn’t/couldn’t make the rain fall. Neither did I. Right?
Besides if we can make believe in anything, why thinks cannot always be like we believe/wish. For example, no matter how hard I tried to make my self-fulfilling prophecy that I would win a lottery this time, it never happened. I even tried another way round, that I would never won lottery, well, just in case I could break this spell, I still never won it.
Oh! or did this self-fulfilling prophecy really work, just only in the negative way?